Ms Caro (shown at left) has had an interesting, if lopsided, career. Heavily praised for her second full-length feature, the simple-minded, so-so Whale Rider (2002), that film still proved an international success. She went on to make a better American movie North Country (2005), with Charlize Theron, that did little business. Now comes Vintner/
Vintage, first seen under its original title at the Toronto International Film Festival way back in 2009 but only last month becoming available here in the USA via DVD. (And in a not very sterling transfer. A film this beautiful absolutely deserves a Blu-ray release!)
If Whale Rider put Ms Caro (and its star, Keisha Castle-Hughes) on the map, it's this film (also starring Ms Castle-Hughes, above) that will, over time, most burnish her reputation. While Whale Rider offered little content in a too-lengthy running time (granted, what there was probably seemed quite exotic to international audiences), this wine-and-love story is filled with content -- and character, history, mystery and... an angel. The manner in which Ms Caro handles this "other-worldly" creature is exemplary: We first see but a suggestion of the winged figure. And then, he is simply there -- bright as something white in the night -- and absolutely real. That he is played by the fine French actor Gaspard Ulliel, below, who makes at once the hunkiest and most beautiful (and intelligent!) angel ever (eat your heart out John Phillip Law) almost immediately takes the movie to new territory.
Into this mix comes a Baroness, set to inherit the vast estate and its vineyards upon which our vintner lives and works. As played by the wonderful Vera Farmiga, below, in one of her best roles (yes, she's has a lot of these), the character is reticent and proud, deep and genuine, and adds as much as do our two males to the richly evolving story.
Why, you may ask (as did I), is the angel even in this tale? Is he a metaphor? What does he represent? Well, in some ways, he is at the heart of things, and so beautifully is he acted by Ulliel that I would not have wanted to lose him. He may represent the other half of Sobran -- aren't we often, as Jacob did Biblically, wrestling with angels of our better (or worse) nature? Because the film is also about life, in all its complexity -- work, love, sex, creation -- this fellow also offers wisdom and help, as well as some other things. He's mysterious, sexual and loving, certainly beyond easy explanation and -- thank god -- beyond the ridiculous tenents of our worldly religions. And this is all for the best.
The movie is gorgeously photographed, and its sets and costumes seems both original and on the mark. And Ms Caro has either guided her actors well (the film is so perfectly cast that perhaps she needed only to trust their talent and intelligence) or let them have their lead in order to run with it. In her screenplay, she and her co-writer have allowed events and character to unfold gradually and graciously so that nothing seems forced.
The filmmaker does not over-explain but rather leaves it to us to do the moderately heavy-lifting it takes to satisfy our need for explanation, theory, closure. (The movie does have a nice arc -- with the beginning, in which we know almost nothing, coming home full circle by the finale.) We learn a lot in and from this movie -- and still leave it pondering. Which is, I think, as it should be.












4 comments:
Loved the book and after 2 viewings I have come to like the film too. I agree with your review but I would recommend reading the book first as there is so much more to know about the story.
This truly is a beautiful film and really warranted a North America theatrical release. I saw it several times at TIFF and am confounded why it did not receive theatrical release. Still, good to have it on dvd. Highly recommend it. Caro is a brilliant director and the cast superb. You will never see anything like it!
Neil Warren
Thanks for commenting, Occasional Pat. And I am sure you are right. Movies can rarely pack in everything that a novel does.
So readers, if you've gotten this far along in the post and comments, please take OP's advice and read the novel first. You'll be doing yourself a favor.
And, Pat -- I am glad you've come to like the film, too!
Neil-- I am sure I would have felt the same way at Toronto, had I been there. I certainly agree with you that the film ought to have found a theatrical release, and yes, I, too, have never seen anything quite like it.
Thanks for your comment!
Post a Comment